ABSTRACT
Objectives: - To evaluate determinants of prescribing for the
elderly in primary care such as diagnoses types, sources and availability
of medications.
Design: - Cross sectional study of elderly patients in primary
care.
Setting / Institution: -Training primary care center in Riyadh (AL
Rabwah primary care center)
Subjects: - 100 elderly patients randomly selected from Rabwah
primary care center
Main Measures: - Number of concomitant diseases, diagnoses,
number, types and sources of medications for elderly in primary care.
Results: - The study showed 51% of patients are being followed up
in primary care center, 56% of patients had two and more diseases,
and 31% of patients are on three or more medications. 61% of patients
get their medications form primary care center and 95% of elderly
medications may be available in primary care center.
Conclusions: - Most of elderly patients depend on primary care
center for their health care.
Well-organized elderly care system need to be in effect urgently in
primary care settings coupled with appropriate educational programs
for the health care team members.
Key words: Health, Prescribing, Elderly, primary care.
Introduction:
The global increase in people aged 60 years and above had attracted
the attention of the world to the magnitude of the problems of providing
health care for the elderly(1).
The proportion of geriatric population
in developed countries reached between 12 and 18% of total population
and expected to increase in coming years(2,3), a phenomenon known
as the "baby boomers" in the west. Similar changes noticed
in developing countries(4), and Saudi Arabia is not an exception.
In Saudi Arabia studies on general population in primary health care
PHC showed an average of 3.2 ± 0.04 drugs per prescription and an
average of 1.8 ± 0.3 drugs per patient. Higher numbers are expected
to be found in the elderly population which composes about 20.7% of
patients attending PHC (5.6).
Traditional teaching suggests that a prescription should be safe,
necessary, effective and economical.
Since increasing number of elderly patients, a group with special
medical needs, will be seen in PHC, the objective of the present study
was conducted to evaluate the essential drugs list available now (7)
taking into consideration the needs of this age group.
Subjects and methods:
This is a cross sectional study that was conducted in Riyadh. During
April-July 2001.
The study population was elderly patients aged 60 years and above,
who were registered in a training (Rabwah) primary health care (PHC)
center.
A pilot study was conducted in King Fahad PHC center and relevant
changes in questionnaire were made after ward. The final questionnaire
completed included the following: -
1. Demographic data such as age, gender, level of education
and place for follow up of disease.
2. Health variables such as number of concomitant diseases,
diagnoses, number, types, sources and availability of medications
used by patient, whether patient is using any medical appliances and
information related to it, i.e. devices like diabetes kits.
The
population in the area covered by Rabwah PHC center is 27,042 of whom
85% were registered in the center. The elderly account for 2671 (9.8%)
in this populace.
The study sample is composed of 100 registered elderly patients 50
male and 50 female patients selected randomly. This number represents
3.7% of the elderly population living in Rabwah.
Physicians working in Rabwah PHC center interviewed all patients.
The data was entered and analyzed in a personal computer using "Data
Star Software for data entry "Systat" Software-version 9"
for statistical analysis .
Results:
The total number of elderly patients involved in the study was 100
out of which (50%) were females. The overall mean age was 66.8 year
± 5.8. (Between 60 to 85 years) (Table 1). Fifty one percent
of patients are followed up in PHC center, while 49% of patients are
being followed up in both PHC and hospital.
Forty four percent of patients were found to have one disease while
32% of patients had two diseases. Patients who had three diseases
or more accounted for 24%. Table 2 shows that more than half
the sample size (56%) represented with at least two or more diseases.
Table
1: Age - sex distribution of the elderly participants
|
Age
group
(year) |
No.
of patients (M=50, F=50)
Male (%) Female (%)
|
Total
(100) |
60-69 |
28
(56%) |
38
(76%) |
66
(66%) |
70-79 |
19
(38%) |
11
(22%) |
30
(30%) |
≥
80 |
3
(6%) |
1
(2%) |
4
(4%) |
Table
2: Number
of diseases by sex in elderly patients involved in the study
|
Age
group
(year) |
No.
of patients (M=50, F=50)
Male (%) Female (%)
|
Total
(100) |
One
disease |
21
(42%) |
23
(46%) |
44
(44%) |
Two
diseases |
11
(22%) |
21
(42%) |
32(32%) |
Three
diseases or more |
18(36%) |
6(12%) |
24(24%) |
The
diagnosis most commonly seen in elderly patients was endocrine and
metabolic diseases mainly diabetes mellitus followed by diseases of
cardiovascular system CVS mainly hypertension. Musculoskeletal and
joint diseases represented only 9% (Table 3). Forty three percent
of patients are using only one medication (Table 4).
Table 3: Classification of diseases by gender
in elderly patients involved in the study.
|
Diseases
|
No. of patients (M=50(F=50)
Male (%) Female
(%)
|
Total
(100)
|
Endocrine and Metabolic disease
|
23
(46%)
|
19
(38%)
|
42
(42%)
|
Cardiovascular
system
|
13
(26%)
|
21
(42%)
|
34
(34%)
|
Musculoskeletal
and joint diseases
|
5
(10%)
|
4
(8%)
|
9
(9%)
|
Respiratory
system diseases
|
3
(6%)
|
4
(8%)
|
7
(7%)
|
Digestive
system disorder
|
2
(4%)
|
0
|
2
(2%)
|
Others
|
4
(8%)
|
2
(4%)
|
6
(6%)
|
Table 4: Number of medications by gender for
elderly patients involved in the study.
|
No.
of medication
|
No.
of patients (M=50)(F=50)
Male
(%)
Female (%)
|
Total
(100)
|
One
medication
|
17
(34%)
|
26
(25%)
|
43
(43%)
|
Two
medications
|
12
(24%)
|
14
(28%)
|
26
(26%)
|
Three
medications
|
8
(16%)
|
4
(8%)
|
12
(12%)
|
Four
medications
|
7
(14%)
|
2
(4%)
|
9
(9%)
|
Five
or more
|
6
(12%)
|
4
(8%)
|
10
(10%)
|
Almost
one third of patients are on three or more medications.
Type: Forty five percent of elderly patients are on drugs for
Diabetes, 34% of patients on drugs for hypertension, 11% of patients
on drugs for musculoskeletal and joints disease mainly non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs NSAID, 4% of patients on drugs for gastrointestinal
tract GIT mainly antacids and ulcer healing drugs (Table 5)
.Of the above medications 35% were prescribed by physicians in PHC
center, 43% by physicians in both hospital and PHC center and 22%
by physicians in other places.
Table
5: Types of drugs used by patients involved in the study:
|
Type
of drug
|
No.
of patients
(n = 100)
|
(%)
|
Endocrine
system
(Insulin, OHA.. etc.)
|
45
|
(45%)
|
CVS
(Beta blockers,
diuretics.. etc)
|
34
|
(34%)
|
Musculoskeletal
and
joint disease
(NSAIDs.. etc)
|
11
|
(11%)
|
GIT
(ulcer healing
drugs, antacids,.. etc)
|
4
|
(4%)
|
Respiratory
system
(ventolin, Becotide..
etc)
|
4
|
(4%)
|
Eye,
ear and others
|
2
|
(2%)
|
CVS
= cardiovascular system, OHA = oral hypoglycemic agents, GIT = gastrointestinal
tract, NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.
Sources:
The sources from which elderly patients in the study get their
medications were PHC center (61 percent) hospital (8 percent); both
hospital and PHC center (30 percent) and only 1% of patients get their
medications from other places. Indicating that PHC center is the main
source of medications.
Availability: On questioning these elderly patients about availability
of their medications 5% of patients indicated that their medications
are always not available in PHC center, 70% of patients indicated
that their medications are some times available in PHC center, while
25% of patients indicated that their medications are always available
in PHC center.
Discussion:
This study has shown that the health care for the majority of elderly
patients is provided by PHC center that agree with previous publications
(8) .
More than half the sample size had two or more diseases with endocrine
and metabolic the commonest encountered diseases, which is expected
in this age group. The prevalence of diabetes is known to increase
with age; therefore it is not an unexpected finding in this study
that diabetes mellitus was at the top of the list of metabolic diseases
seen in elderly patients. This also explains why the medications for
diabetes were the most common drugs used by elderly in PHC.
Conclusions:
Most of elderly patients depend on primary health care for their
health needs. Elderly care system or clinic need to be applied in
primary health care.
Training of physicians, nurses and other health care team members
on needs of elderly patients is highly needed as well as providing
facilities for diagnosis and screening of elderly health problems.
References:
1. Kinsella KG, Velkoff VA, United States. Bureau of the Census.
An aging world : 2001. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Dept. of Commerce
Economics and Statistics Administration ;2001.
2.
Burton JR, Solomon DH. Geriatric Medicine: A true primary care
discipline (editorial). J Am Geriatric Sor. 1993; 41:459-62.
3.
Ageing : the surest demographic reality of the next century . World
Health Organization. 51st year, no 2, 1998.
4.
Information needs for research, policy and action on ageing and
older adults. Report of a workshop on creating a minimum data set
for research, policy and action on ageing and the aged
in Africa, WHO, Harare, Zimbabwe;2000.
5.
Khoja T, Al-Shammari S, Farag MK, AL-Mazrou Y. Quality of
prescribing at primary care centers in Saudi Arabia. J Pharma Tech.
1996; 12:284-88.
6.
Al-Shammari S, Nass M, Al-Maatouq M, al-Quaiaz J. Family
practice in Saudi Arabia: Chronic morbidity and quality of care.
Int J Quality Health Care. 1996;8(4): 383-87.
7.
Drug formulary for health centers, Revised 1994. Ministry of health.
General directorate of health centers. Saudi Arabia.
8.
Health of the elderly. Background document. WHO executive board
95th session, 1995.
9.
Bretherton A, Day L,Lewis G. Polypharmacy and older people. Nurs
Times. 2003;99(17):54-5.